Thursday, May 24, 2012
bLoG pOsT nUmBeR sEvEn
In my opinion, a non-fiction book has to be mostly true. I am fine if the writer doesn't tell the whole truth, just a white lie. An example of that would be saying if the author had one dog and his neighbor had another. Instead of talking about the neighbor and his dog, why not just say you have two dogs or just leave that dog out of the situation. I don't think that it's okay that Frey and Mortenson bent the truth to tell their stories. They should have been honest and say that some of the events in the book were exaggerated or made up. Plus, why do they want them to memoirs so badly? It would make life easier for them if they just made it a regular book instead then they wouldn't have any crap about lying. I think that David Shields is both right and wrong. Right because we shouldn't have to label something, a book is a book and some people may enjoy it and some people may not. Wrong because, in my opinion, the only reason we have genres is so that people know where to look when they want a specific book at the book store. So overall, i think that David is more right then wrong.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Agree with most of this but I do not agree with it is ok to lie, that is a horrid thing and should not be allowed in the true section, I think that books should be labeled because its fun to see all of the different ones that we have
ReplyDeleteI see why you think it's okay to tell the little white lies. There's times when it's appropriate, but there's also times when it's not a good idea to
ReplyDeleteI agree just I think it's fair to ask that 95% be true for the sake of the author and the reader. When the author tell stoo many lies I don't think you can consider it non-fiction anymore.
ReplyDeleteI believe the write should tell the whole truth. If his life needs some pizzazz to make it good then why write about it?
ReplyDeleteI agree that a nonfiction book has to be mostly true. I agree that in certian situations it is okay for the writer of a nonfiction book to tell a little white lie, but only about certian things and only about small details.
ReplyDeleteWould you ever change genre labels?
ReplyDeletei agree that it should be true with twists here and there but no lying. A twist here and there like i said but no outright lies.
ReplyDeleteWRONG!
ReplyDelete